Before anyone pays an unfamiliar invoice this December, three things should be true: a real purchase order or contract backs it up, someone looked up the vendor independently instead of trusting the number on the bill, and nobody called a number from a “dispute this charge” email. Scammers count on year-end chaos — early AP cutoffs, out-of-office approvers, a bookkeeper rushing to close the books — to get a fake invoice for “domain renewal,” “SEO services” or a “subscription past due” paid without a second look. Here’s a short routine for whoever handles your bills, plus what to do if someone already paid or picked up the phone.
1. Confirm a real purchase order or contract exists
Every legitimate invoice traces back to something concrete: a purchase order, a signed contract, or an email thread where someone at your company actually agreed to the charge. If nobody can produce that trail in a couple of minutes, don’t pay it “to be safe” and sort it out later. The FTC’s own guidance to small businesses is blunt on this point: have clear, written procedures for approving invoices, and only pay vendors your company actually works with.
In practice this means the invoice should name a person, a date, and a service your team remembers requesting. Fake invoices for tech support, domain registration, directory listings and SEO are built to look like routine paperwork — a real-looking account number, a due date, familiar vendor language — because they’re hard to tell apart from a legitimate renewal at a glance.
2. Look up the vendor yourself — don’t use the number on the bill
Any phone number or email address printed on the invoice itself should be treated as unverified, because scammers print their own contact details right on the fake bill. Instead, find the vendor’s number through your own records or a past invoice you know was real, then call that number and ask whether the charge is legitimate.
The FTC also recommends a quick gut check before paying anyone new: search the company’s name alongside words like “review,” “scam,” or “complaint.” A vendor that’s been invoicing hundreds of businesses for services nobody ordered usually has a visible trail of complaints within the first page of results.
3. Never call a number printed on a ‘dispute this charge’ message
Any message that says “dispute this charge within 24 hours or you’ll be billed $499” is very often the scam itself, not a notice about one. This is the same playbook as fake antivirus-renewal emails that tell you to call now to avoid a charge — the callback number connects you to the scammer, not a real company, and the goal is usually a card number or remote access to a computer under the guise of “processing the refund.”
What good looks like: if a renewal or charge looks wrong, go to the account directly through a bookmarked login or a number from a prior statement, never through a link or number in the message that raised the alarm in the first place.
4. Require a second approver above a set dollar amount
A second signature above a set threshold — $250 or $500 is a reasonable starting point for a small office — works because a second person without the same deadline pressure is more likely to pause and ask questions. This doesn’t need to be formal software; it can be as simple as a rule that any invoice over that amount gets a two-line email confirmation from someone outside accounts payable before it’s paid.
This habit matters more at year-end than any other time. Whoever approves large payments is often out of office in late December, which is exactly when a fake “past due” notice is most likely to get rubber-stamped by someone covering for them under time pressure.
5. What to do if someone already paid or already called
Speed matters most once money or information has actually moved. If the payment went on a card, call the card issuer immediately to dispute the charge. If it went out by ACH or wire, call your bank right away — a wire can sometimes be recalled within a narrow window that closes fast. If someone paid with gift cards and read off the codes, contact the card issuer immediately; those are close to impossible to reverse once the codes are used.
If someone called a number from a suspicious message and gave remote access to a computer, disconnect that machine from the network immediately and have IT check it for malware or remote-access tools before reconnecting it. Either way, report the incident at ReportFraud.ftc.gov, forward phishing emails to reportphishing@apwg.org, and for larger losses, file a complaint with the FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center at ic3.gov.
The bottom line
None of this requires new software or a security budget — it requires a routine that survives a distracted December: confirm the paper trail, verify vendors independently, and put a second set of eyes on anything above a set dollar amount. Fake-invoice and business email compromise scams cost businesses billions of dollars a year precisely because they target process gaps, not technical ones — and a five-minute habit closes most of that gap for free.
Want a second opinion on your accounts-payable process before year-end? Book a free 30-minute consult and we’ll look at how invoices get approved in your office — and tell you honestly whether your current routine would catch a fake one.