Windows 10 support ended in October 2025, and plenty of offices still have a few of those PCs on desks, or a lot of them. They still turn on and they still run QuickBooks, so replacing them never makes the top of the list. But the clock is now running on two costs at once. Microsoft’s paid security updates double in price every year, and new PCs cost more than they did a year ago because of a worldwide memory shortage.

There are only three real options for each machine: pay Microsoft for another year of security updates, upgrade it to Windows 11 for free, or replace it. Here’s how to sort a 25-PC office into those three groups, and what each choice actually costs.

1. Know what you’re paying for with extended updates

Microsoft’s Extended Security Updates (ESU) program keeps Windows 10 PCs getting critical and important security fixes after support ends. For businesses it costs $61 per PC for the first year, and Microsoft’s own ESU page says the price doubles every year, for three years at most. By that rule, year two is $122 per PC and year three is $244. Year two starts in mid-October 2026, and coverage ends for good in October 2028.

Two details catch people out. First, ESU is cumulative: if you skipped year one and sign up now, Microsoft charges you for year one too, so your first year costs $183 per PC. Second, ESU is only security patches. It includes no new features, no general technical support, and nothing that makes an old PC faster or more reliable.

2. Check which PCs can take Windows 11 for free

The upgrade from Windows 10 to Windows 11 costs nothing in licensing if the hardware qualifies. Microsoft’s minimum requirements are 4 GB of RAM, 64 GB of storage, UEFI firmware with Secure Boot, TPM 2.0, and a supported 64-bit processor. In practice the processor is what rules most machines out. As a rough guide, Intel 8th-generation Core chips and AMD Ryzen 2000-series and newer are on the list, which usually means PCs from about 2018 onward.

How to check: On each PC, open Settings, then Windows Update. If it says the PC can run Windows 11, you’re done. If you’re not sure, install Microsoft’s free PC Health Check app and run the check. If a fairly new machine fails only on TPM or Secure Boot, the setting is often just turned off in the BIOS, and it’s worth a look before you write the PC off.

3. Sort every PC into keep, upgrade, or replace

Once you’ve checked every machine, put each one in a group:

The goal is to make the ESU group as small as possible and to have a reason written down for every PC in it.

4. Run the numbers for a 25-PC office

Here’s an illustrative example, not a quote. Say 10 of your 25 PCs pass the Windows 11 check and 15 don’t. Upgrading the 10 costs nothing in licensing. For the other 15, there are two paths.

If you keep all 15 on ESU through October 2028 and skipped year one, you pay $183 per PC now and $244 next year, about $6,400 in total. At the end you still own 15 PCs that are at least ten years old and have no support left, and you still have to replace them. If you replace them now and figure an illustrative $900 to $1,300 per business-grade PC, that’s roughly $13,500 to $19,500. That’s more cash up front, but it buys hardware with a warranty that will last for years, instead of paying for patches on machines you’ll throw away anyway.

The middle path is usually the right one: replace the oldest and most troublesome PCs now, pay one year of ESU on the rest, and replace those next year. That spreads the cost over two budgets without paying the $244 year-three price.

5. Factor in memory prices before you wait

The other cost moving against you is hardware. AI data centers are buying up memory chips, and Dell, HP and Lenovo have all raised PC prices in 2026. Industry reports put the increases at around 15 to 20 percent, and higher on models with more memory. Nobody can promise where prices go next, so we wouldn’t buy early as a bet. The practical step is to get quotes now, budget with today’s prices plus some cushion, and don’t count on PCs getting cheaper by next fall.

What good looks like: a spreadsheet listing every PC with its age, its Windows 11 check result, its group, and a replacement month. If you can’t produce that list in an afternoon, start there.

The bottom line

ESU is a bridge, and a toll that doubles every year. Use it to buy time for the PCs that truly can’t move yet, not as a way to avoid the decision. Upgrade every machine that qualifies, replace the ones that don’t on a schedule you choose, and keep the ESU group small and short-lived. Windows 10 PCs will keep working without patches, but each unpatched machine is an open door into everything else on your network.

Not sure which of your PCs fall in which group? Book a free 30-minute consult and we’ll help you sort your machines into keep, upgrade and replace — and tell you honestly which ones are worth paying Microsoft to keep alive.